Course:
Teaching reviewing to graduate students by Jens Palsberg
Course:
Scholarship Skills by Andrew Black OGI
MockPC
Course:
Reviewing in compiler technology
Lecture on Aspects of reviewing
Conference paper review:
Identify the Champion
by
Oscar Nierstrasz
Reviewing papers
hints
by
Jeff Offutt
Reviewing:
Major revision or Reject?
by
Jeff Offutt
Citations:
Why do we cite papers?
by
Jeff Offutt
Inside Peer Review
by Donald Christiansen, IEEE Today's Engineer
Reviewing papers
by John Ousterhout (Berkeley)
Teaching Reviewing to Graduate Students
, Jens Palsberg and Scott J. Baxter, CACM 45(12), December 2002.
John Ousterhout's Hints for Reviewing Papers
via Armando Fox
Jeff Offutt's Reviewing Papers slides
Norman Ramsey's Resources for Writers
The Task of the Referee
by Alan Jay Smith, IEEE Computer 1990
Parbury: A guide for new referees,
Experience in literature review
Michael J. Hanson and Dylan J. McNamee,
Efficient Reading of Papers in Science and Technology
Resources about Reviewing Papers (from
Wilson
)
Some sample review forms:
PPoPP 99
,
PLDI 01
.
A Guide to New Referees in Theoretical Computer Science
by Ian Parberry